A developer is once again seeking permission to demolish three buildings nestled in the heart of State Street, proposing to replace them with a six-story housing project coupled with commercial spaces, the Wisconsin State Journal reports.
After 18 months of efforts, the city’s Plan Commission rejected JD McCormick Properties’ initial bid late last June to raze the three two-story buildings situated at 428-430, 432-436, and 440-444 State Street. Notably, two of these structures have roots dating back to the late 1800s, located adjacent to Lisa Link Peace Park.
In the proposed plan, these buildings would give way to a six-story structure featuring 25 housing units and 6,285 square feet of commercial space on the basement and ground levels.
Despite the initial refusal, the commission hinted at the possibility of reconsideration if McCormick could furnish additional evidence supporting their case for demolition. Subsequently, McCormick’s renewed request offers more substantial documentation, including photographs, showcasing the deteriorating interiors and other structural issues within the existing buildings.
The project’s design has undergone revisions over time, with the latest iteration comprising four stories fronting State Street and an additional setback story. It includes commercial spaces totaling 3,350 square feet on the ground floor and 2,935 square feet in the basement, featuring a rooftop deck atop the fourth floor.
Previously, opinions from Capitol Neighborhoods Inc. varied regarding the project, while the Madison Trust for Historic Preservation opposed it, citing the significance of the three buildings representing over a century of State Street’s character. The Landmarks Commission emphasized the historical value of the older structures, while the Urban Design Commission recommended approval, with the City Planning Division staff supporting the proposal subject to specific conditions.
